Stock phrases in 18th century musical style
One might assume that the creation of compelling music is a spontaneous act of genius, a divine spark unburdened by convention. Yet, even in the supposedly "enlightened" 18th century, composers, much like their modern counterparts, relied on a repertoire of established patterns and recognizable gestures. These are the "stock musical phrases" of Galant music, meticulously cataloged as Galant Schemata by Robert Gjerdingen in his seminal work, Music in the Galant Style. The very notion of a musical schema, in this context, draws its theoretical underpinnings from schema theory in psychology, suggesting that our minds, both as creators and perceivers, organize and interpret information based on pre-existing mental frameworks. It's less about raw inspiration and more about navigating a familiar landscape.
Each of these schemata, rather than being a mere suggestion, possesses a remarkably consistent internal architecture. They are defined by discernible characteristics such as precise voice leading, a specific number of constituent "events"—individual harmonic or melodic gestures—and a clear delineation of relative metric strength and weakness within these events. Furthermore, these schemata are not merely isolated fragments; they occupy normative, predictable positions within the larger musical structure. According to Gjerdingen, the seamless and conventional deployment of these schemata isn't just a convenient compositional shortcut; it's practically "a hallmark of the galant style." This reliance on structured patterns, he posits, is a direct consequence of the rigorous partimento pedagogical tradition that flourished in the Neapolitan conservatories of the era. Students weren't just taught to improvise; they were drilled in a grammar of musical phrases, ensuring a common stylistic language. Broadly speaking, these indispensable galant schemata can be categorized by their functional placement within a musical phrase: those that initiate, those that conclude, those that confirm (cadential), those that prepare for confirmation (pre-cadential), and those that provide a post-confirmation lingering thought.
Opening Schemata
The beginning of any musical statement requires a certain gravitas, or at least a recognizable point of departure. The galant style provided several such initial gestures, each with its own character and implications.
Romanesca
The Romanesca, a melodic and harmonic pattern of considerable antiquity, traces its origins back to the 16th and 17th centuries. In those earlier times, it served as a ubiquitous musical backdrop, often in a minor key, for the expressive singing of poetry, and as a fertile ground for variations built upon a repeating harmonic progression. Its enduring appeal meant it transcended eras, evolving into its later galant form. This later incarnation of the Romanesca retains a similar fundamental progression but manifests in three distinct variants: the "leaping" variant, characterized by more disjunct melodic motion; the "stepwise" variant, which, predictably, emphasizes conjunct motion; and the "galant" variant, a pragmatic hybrid that selectively combines elements from its two predecessors. Gjerdingen aptly characterizes the Romanesca as an "opening gambit," a strategic first move, implying that its conventional placement is invariably at the very inception of a phrasal structure. Melodically, a Romanesca typically lends particular emphasis to scale degrees 1 and 5, anchoring the listener's ear to the tonic and dominant, the foundational pillars of Western tonality.
- Prototype of a leaping Romanesca.
- Stepwise variant of the Romanesca.
Meyer, Jupiter, Pastorella, and Aprile
The Meyer schema, a testament to efficiency and structural clarity, was a particularly popular choice among galant composers for themes that carried significant structural weight within a piece. It presents a concise, four-event structure, invariably organized into two pairs of two, or "dyads." The melodic trajectory of the Meyer is quite specific: the first pair of events features a descent, often quite prominent, from scale degree 1 down to scale degree 7. Following this, the second pair continues the descent, moving from scale degree 4 to scale degree 3. Concurrently, the bassline provides a foundational counterpoint: a stepwise ascent from scale degree 1 to scale degree 2 occurs during the first melodic pair, followed by another stepwise ascent from scale degree 7 to scale degree 1 in the second pair of events. This ingenious interplay between melody and bass establishes a clear harmonic narrative: the first pair of events distinctly outlines a tonic function moving towards a dominant function, effectively "opening" the harmonic progression. The second pair then resolves this tension, shifting from a dominant function back to a tonic function, thereby "closing" the phrase with a sense of completion.
The Meyer, being such a versatile and effective construct, spawned three closely related schemata, each offering a subtle melodic modification while preserving the underlying harmonic and bass structure. These are the Jupiter, the Pastorella, and the Aprile. Their primary distinctions lie in their melodic contours, offering composers a palette of slightly different expressive nuances for essentially the same structural purpose.
- The Jupiter, famously named after Mozart's Symphony No. 41, features a melody that outlines scale degree 1 to scale degree 2 in its opening pair of events, resolving with scale degree 4 to scale degree 3 in its closing pair. It's a brisk, assertive variant.
- The Pastorella melody, in contrast, presents a gentler, more lyrical opening, moving from scale degree 3 to scale degree 2, before concluding with scale degree 4 to scale degree 3. This variant often imparts a pastoral or reflective character.
- Lastly, the Aprile melody offers a distinct melodic profile, beginning with scale degree 1 descending to scale degree 7 in the opening, and then ascending from scale degree 2 to scale degree 1 in the closing. This creates a slightly more introspective or perhaps even melancholic feel.
Despite these melodic variations, the fundamental bassline and harmonic function remain remarkably consistent across the Meyer, Jupiter, Pastorella, and Aprile. All four variants reliably establish a clear progression from tonic function to dominant function in their opening segments, and then from dominant function back to tonic function in their closing segments, providing a solid, predictable harmonic foundation.
- Prototype of the Meyer.
- Prototype of the Jupiter.
- Prototype of the Pastorella.
- Prototype of the Aprile.
Do-Re-Mi
The Do-Re-Mi schema is another remarkably common "opening gambit," a foundational building block for starting a musical phrase. It is characterized by its elegant simplicity and immediate recognizability. This schema typically comprises three distinct events, and as its very name suggests, the melody almost invariably features a clear, stepwise ascent from scale degree 1 (Do) to scale degree 3 (Mi). This rising melodic line provides a sense of forward momentum and directness. In the bass, two common patterns serve to underpin this melodic motion: a stepwise progression from scale degree 1 to scale degree 7, and then back to scale degree 1, or a more direct movement from scale degree 1 to scale degree 5, returning to scale degree 1. These three events collectively imply a straightforward harmonic progression: a stable tonic function for the first event, a moment of tension or departure via a dominant function in the second event, and a return to the grounding tonic function in the third event, thus establishing the key with clarity. A notable variant, sometimes referred to as the Adeste Fidelis variant, introduces a touch of melodic embellishment by featuring pronounced leaps down to scale degree 5 within the melodic line, adding a slightly more dramatic or expansive quality to this otherwise straightforward schema.
- Prototype of the Do-Re-Mi.
- The Adeste Fidelis Variant of the Do-Re-Mi.
Sol-Fa-Mi
The Sol-Fa-Mi stands as yet another "opening gambit" in the galant lexicon, though it possesses a distinctly different character from its more assertive counterparts like the Do-Re-Mi or the Meyer. It is generally perceived as less bold, more understated, and consequently found its typical application in the more reflective realms of slow movement themes or as secondary, less prominent material within faster, more complex movements. This schema is elegantly presented as a pair of dyads, a sequence of four events grouped into two sets of two. The first dyad initiates with a melody that gently steps down from scale degree 5 (Sol) to scale degree 4 (Fa), simultaneously supported by a bass line that steps up from scale degree 1 to scale degree 2. The second dyad continues this melodic descent, moving from scale degree 4 to scale degree 3 (Mi), while the bass completes its upward journey, stepping from scale degree 7 to scale degree 1. This careful, almost hesitant, progression lends the Sol-Fa-Mi its characteristic sense of introspection and delicate unfolding, making it ideal for moments requiring subtle grace rather than overt declaration.
- Prototype of the Sol-Fa-Mi.
Closing Schemata
Just as music needs a clear beginning, it demands a satisfying conclusion. These "closing schemata" provide the necessary harmonic and melodic punctuation, bringing phrases and sections to a convincing close.
Prinner
The Prinner, as Gjerdingen provocatively describes it, functions as a "riposte" to an opening schema. It’s not merely an ending, but a direct, often emphatic, response, a definitive statement following an initial proposition. A Prinner melody is defined by some form of stepwise descent, typically spanning from scale degree 6 down to scale degree 3. This descending melodic line is underpinned by a bassline that mirrors this motion, executing a stepwise descent from scale degree 4 to scale degree 1. This parallel motion, or sometimes contrary motion, creates a strong sense of directed movement towards a point of rest. A common variant of this schema exists, incorporating an optional extension in the third event where scale degree 5 is introduced in the bass. This subtle yet effective addition serves to significantly strengthen the finality of the musical phrase, providing a more robust and unambiguous conclusion, leaving no doubt as to the phrase's resolution.
- Prototype of the Prinner.
Modulating Prinners
The inherent utility and clear directional pull of the Prinner made it an invaluable tool for composers in the galant period, especially when faced with the compositional necessity of modulating from one key to another. Specifically, Prinners were frequently employed as an elegant and efficient means to transition from an established key to its dominant. When utilized in this manner, these variations are specifically distinguished as modulating Prinners. Their structure is subtly adapted to ensure that the arrival on the new dominant feels not merely like a temporary deviation, but a purposeful, structurally integrated shift, setting the stage for subsequent musical development in the new tonal center.
Fonte
The Fonte, a closing schema of considerable elegance and versatility, unfolds across four distinct events, meticulously organized into two groups of two, or "dyads." The first of these groups presents a pair of harmonies firmly rooted in a minor key, immediately establishing a contrasting, often slightly melancholic, tonal color. The second group, however, shifts decisively into a major key, providing a sense of resolution or brighter affirmation. Composers masterfully utilized the Fonte as a sophisticated mechanism to briefly, yet effectively, deviate from the main key of a piece. In essence, the first group of events achieves this by temporarily tonicizing the supertonic of the main key, creating a momentary harmonic detour. This is then gracefully followed by the second group, which orchestrates a clear cadential action, firmly re-establishing the main key and bringing the phrase to a conclusive close. The Fonte melody typically features two recognizable melodic sets, each corresponding precisely to one of the two harmonic groups. A crucial characteristic is that the second melodic set in a Fonte is invariably a step lower than the first set, creating a descending melodic sequence that reinforces the harmonic progression. This schema shares a conceptual kinship with the descending fifth sequence, a fundamental pattern of harmonic movement that underpins much tonal music.
- A Fonte prototype.
Monte
The Monte schema, much like its counterpart the Fonte, also features its constituent events thoughtfully grouped into pairs. However, the Monte exhibits a slightly more flexible historical development. Early examples of the Monte schema were not strictly bound to a two-section structure; it was not uncommon to find them with more than two distinct sections, allowing for greater expansion. Yet, as the galant style matured and solidified its conventions, later Montes predominantly featured two primary sections. The first of these sections would typically contain two harmonic events, strategically centering around the subdominant of the main key, creating a sense of gentle expansion or preparation. The second section would then also comprise two events, but these would invariably center around the dominant, usually culminating in the formation of a clear and satisfying cadence. Melodically, the Monte is characterized by its distinctive ascending pattern: the second section is typically a near-exact melodic copy of the first, but transposed a step higher, creating a sense of rising intensity or aspiration. The bassline of the Monte also usually features a clear melodic ascent, reinforcing this upward trajectory. Conceptually, the Monte bears a strong resemblance to the ascending tenths sequence, another fundamental pattern that contributes to its sense of directed, purposeful motion.
- A Monte prototype.
Ponte
The Ponte schema serves a very specific and often crucial function within galant music: it acts as a deliberate prolongation of a dominant sonority. It's the musical equivalent of holding one's breath just before a resolution, stretching out the tension. A Ponte melody typically emphasizes and reiterates the tones that belong to the dominant or dominant seventh harmony, keeping the ear focused on this point of harmonic tension. Concurrently, the bass line features repetitions of the fifth scale degree, often evolving into an outright pedal point. This sustained bass note, combined with the melodic emphasis on dominant-related tones, creates a stable yet expectant harmonic state, effectively delaying the eventual tonic resolution and building anticipation for the phrase's conclusion. It’s a moment of suspended animation, a lingering on the edge of certainty.
- A Ponte prototype.
Cadences
See also: Partimento § Cadences
The very backbone of musical punctuation, cadences are the ultimate arbiters of phrase endings, providing moments of rest, finality, or semi-finality. In the galant style, these crucial points of arrival were often categorized into specific, recognizable schemata: the Cadenza Semplice (or simple cadence), a straightforward and direct conclusion; the Cadenza Composta (or compound cadence), offering a slightly more elaborate and often more conclusive resolution; and the Cadenza Doppia (or double cadence), which, as its name suggests, provides an even more reinforced sense of finality, often by doubling or reiterating key cadential gestures. Each type served a distinct rhetorical purpose in shaping the musical discourse.
Pre-Cadences
Before the inevitable arrival of a cadence, composers often employed "pre-cadential" schemata—musical gestures designed to prepare the listener for the impending resolution, building anticipation and guiding the harmonic trajectory.
Fenaroli
Named after the influential Neapolitan theorist and composer Fedele Fenaroli, this pre-cadential schema is a testament to the systematic teaching of compositional patterns. The Fenaroli typically comprises four events. Its melody begins with a descent from scale degree 4 to scale degree 3, creating a sense of approaching resolution, which is then followed by a decisive ascent from scale degree 7 to scale degree 1, strongly leading into the tonic. The bass of the Fenaroli provides a clear, stepwise ascent from scale degree 7 to scale degree 3, moving in a purposeful manner towards the dominant. Another common melodic variant for the Fenaroli features a progression from scale degree 2 to scale degree 3, followed by scale degree 7 to scale degree 1. This particular melodic configuration often creates a sophisticated canon with the bass line, where the melodic voice imitates the bass, but at a different interval and often slightly delayed, adding a layer of contrapuntal interest and complexity. Furthermore, a specific countermelody, widely taught and systematized by the renowned Francesco Durante, exists for the Fenaroli, further illustrating its integration into the pedagogical traditions of the era and its adaptability within various contrapuntal textures.
- Prototype of the Fenaroli.
- Fenaroli prototype where the melody creates a canon with the bass.
- Fenaroli prototype with the Durante countermelody.
Indugio
If the Ponte is about prolonging the dominant, the Indugio is its counterpart, focusing on the deliberate prolongation of a predominant sonority. It's a calculated pause, a moment of heightened expectation before a half cadence—the musical equivalent of drawing a breath before delivering a crucial line. In an Indugio, the melodic line will frequently highlight and emphasize specific scale degrees such as 2, 4, and 6, which are all characteristic tones of predominant harmonies. Simultaneously, the bass line will anchor itself on scale degree 4, or a variant thereof, meticulously preparing the ground for the eventual, and anticipated, movement to scale degree 5, which will then usher in the half cadence. This sustained predominant harmony creates a sense of unresolved tension, ensuring that the subsequent half cadence feels both prepared and satisfyingly incomplete, poised for further musical development.
- Prototype of the Indugio with half cadence
Other Pre-cadences
Beyond these prominent examples, the galant repertoire, with its nuanced approach to musical rhetoric, employed several other pre-cadential schemata. These included the deceptive cadence, which, true to its name, offers an unexpected harmonic turn instead of the anticipated resolution; the evaded cadence, which narrowly avoids a full conclusion, often for expressive purposes; the converging cadence, where multiple voices strategically draw together; the Passo Indietro, a specific backward step in the progression; and the comma, a fleeting pause or rhetorical break. Each of these served to manipulate listener expectation, adding layers of sophistication to the inevitable cadential arrivals.
Post-Cadences
Even after a cadence has firmly established a point of rest, music often requires a brief moment to settle, to confirm the new harmonic reality, or to simply linger. These "post-cadential" schemata provide just such a function.
Quiescenza
The Quiescenza, a schema aptly named for its function, was skillfully employed by galant composers to prolong the tonic harmony immediately following a significant, section-ending cadence. Its purpose is essentially to allow the music to "rest" on a stable tonic, providing a sense of calm and finality after the preceding harmonic activity. This schema's utility, however, extended beyond just concluding sections; it was also frequently, and quite effectively, utilized at the very beginning of pieces. In such instances, its role was to strongly and unambiguously establish the central key, grounding the listener firmly in the tonal landscape from the outset. The Quiescenza is characterized by four distinct events. Its melody typically descends first from the flattened scale degree 7 (b7) to scale degree 6, creating a gentle, almost sighing gesture, and then ascends from scale degree 7 to scale degree 1, resolving definitively to the tonic. Crucially, the bass of the Quiescenza maintains a tonic pedal point for its entire duration. This sustained tonic in the bass provides an unshakable foundation, reinforcing the sense of repose and stability that is the hallmark of this post-cadential schema.
- Prototype of the Quiescenza.
Superimposition of schemata
While it is common, and often pedagogically useful, to analyze schemata as discrete, serially unfolding entities, the true artistry of galant composition often lies in their more complex deployment. Schemata are not merely strung together like beads on a necklace; they can be, and frequently are, superimposed upon one another. This technique involves the simultaneous presentation of elements from different schemata, creating a richer, more intricate contrapuntal and harmonic fabric. Highly contrapuntal works, such as the elaborate textures found in fugues, serve as prime examples of this sophisticated compositional practice, where multiple overlapping schemata contribute to the dense, interwoven musical lines, demanding a more astute ear to unravel their individual threads.
Table of schemata
For those who appreciate the stark clarity of categorization, the following table presents a summary of the principal galant schemata, outlining their characteristic melodic and bass movements, their typical metric emphasis, and their primary functional variety within a musical structure. It's a concise cheat sheet for a complex language.
| Schema | Melody | Bass | Metric polarity | Variety |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| The Romanesca | 1-5-1-1 | 1-7-6-3 | Strong-weak | Opening |
| The Prinner | 6-5-4-(2)-3 | 4-3-2-(5)-1 | Strong-weak | Closing |
| Modulating Prinner | 3-2-1-7 | 8-7-6-5 | Strong-weak | Closing |
| The Fonte | 4-3, then 4-3 one step lower | 7-1, then 7-1 one step lower | Weak-strong | Closing |
| The Do-Re-Mi | 1-2-3 | 1-7-1 | Strong-weak | Opening |
| The Monte | 5-4-3, then 5-4-3 one step higher | 7-1 then 7-1 one step higher | Weak-strong | Closing |
| The Meyer | Open: 1-7 Closed: 4-3 | Open: 1-2 Closed:7-1 | Weak-strong | Opening |
| The Quiescenza | b7-6-7-1 | 1-1-1-1 | Weak-strong | Post-cadential |
| The Ponte | 5-7-2 | 5-5-5 | Strong-weak | Closing |
| The Fenaroli | 4-3-7-1 | 7-1-2-3 | Weak-strong | Pre-cadential |
| The Sol-Fa-Mi | Open: 5-4 Closed: 4-3 | Open: 1-2 Closed: 7-1 | Weak-strong | Opening |
| The Indugio | 2...4-6-1-7 | 4...4-4-4#-5 | Strong-weak | Pre-cadential |
| Cadenza Semplice | 1-2-2-1 | 3-4-5-1 | Weak-strong | Cadence |
| Cadenza Composta | 1-2-3-2-1 | 3-4-5-5-1 | Weak-strong | Cadence |
| Cadenza Doppia | 4-3-2-1 | 5-1 | Strong-weak | Cadence |
See also
Bibliography
- ^ a b Gjerdingen, Robert O. (2020). Music in the galant style. New York, NY. p. 6. ISBN 978-0-19-009581-9. OCLC 1119767298. {{cite book}}: CS1 maint: location missing publisher (link)
- ^ Shaffer, Kris; Gotham, Mark (2021-07-01). "Galant Schemas". {{cite journal}}: Cite journal requires |journal= (help)
- ^ Gotham, Mark (2021-07-01). "Galant Schemas – Summary". {{cite journal}}: Cite journal requires |journal= (help)
- ^ Taruskin, Richard (2019). The Oxford history of Western music. Oxford University Press. ISBN 978-0-19-060022-8. OCLC 1064401150.
- ^ Gjerdingen, Robert O. (2020). Music in the galant style. New York, NY. p. 33. ISBN 978-0-19-009581-9. OCLC 1119767298. {{cite book}}: CS1 maint: location missing publisher (link)
- ^ Gjerdingen, Robert O. (2020). Music in the galant style. New York, NY. p. 454. ISBN 978-0-19-009581-9. OCLC 1119767298. {{cite book}}: CS1 maint: location missing publisher (link)
- ^ a b Gjerdingen, Robert O. (2020). Music in the galant style. New York, NY. p. 459. ISBN 978-0-19-009581-9. OCLC 1119767298. {{cite book}}: CS1 maint: location missing publisher (link)
- ^ Gjerdingen, Robert O. (2020). Music in the galant style. New York, NY. p. 116. ISBN 978-0-19-009581-9. OCLC 1119767298. {{cite book}}: CS1 maint: location missing publisher (link)
- ^ Gjerdingen, Robert O. (2020). Music in the galant style. New York, NY. p. 117. ISBN 978-0-19-009581-9. OCLC 1119767298. {{cite book}}: CS1 maint: location missing publisher (link)
- ^ Gjerdingen, Robert O. (2020). Music in the galant style. New York, NY. p. 122. ISBN 978-0-19-009581-9. OCLC 1119767298. {{cite book}}: CS1 maint: location missing publisher (link)
- ^ Gjerdingen, Robert O. (2020). Music in the galant style. New York, NY. p. 457. ISBN 978-0-19-009581-9. OCLC 1119767298. {{cite book}}: CS1 maint: location missing publisher (link)
- ^ Gjerdingen, Robert O. (2020). Music in the galant style. New York, NY. p. 85. ISBN 978-0-19-009581-9. OCLC 1119767298. {{cite book}}: CS1 maint: location missing publisher (link)
- ^ Gjerdingen, Robert O. (2020). Music in the galant style. New York, NY. p. 463. ISBN 978-0-19-009581-9. OCLC 1119767298. {{cite book}}: CS1 maint: location missing publisher (link)
- ^ Gjerdingen, Robert O. (2020). Music in the galant style. New York, NY. p. 45. ISBN 978-0-19-009581-9. OCLC 1119767298. {{cite book}}: CS1 maint: location missing publisher (link)
- ^ Gjerdingen, Robert O. (2020). Music in the galant style. New York, NY. p. 455. ISBN 978-0-19-009581-9. OCLC 1119767298. {{cite book}}: CS1 maint: location missing publisher (link)
- ^ Gjerdingen, Robert O. (2020). Music in the galant style. New York, NY. p. 456. ISBN 978-0-19-009581-9. OCLC 1119767298. {{cite book}}: CS1 maint: location missing publisher (link)
- ^ Gjerdingen, Robert O. (2020). Music in the galant style. New York, NY. p. 458. ISBN 978-0-19-009581-9. OCLC 1119767298. {{cite book}}: CS1 maint: location missing publisher (link)
- ^ Gjerdingen, Robert O. (2020). Music in the galant style. New York, NY. p. 461. ISBN 978-0-19-009581-9. OCLC 1119767298. {{cite book}}: CS1 maint: location missing publisher (link)
- ^ Gjerdingen, Robert O. (2020). Music in the galant style. New York, NY. p. 462. ISBN 978-0-19-009581-9. OCLC 1119767298. {{cite book}}: CS1 maint: location missing publisher (link)
- ^ Gjerdingen, Robert O. (2020). Music in the galant style. New York, NY. p. 226. ISBN 978-0-19-009581-9. OCLC 1119767298. {{cite book}}: CS1 maint: location missing publisher (link)
- ^ Gjerdingen, Robert O. (2020). Music in the galant style. New York, NY. p. 464. ISBN 978-0-19-009581-9. OCLC 1119767298. {{cite book}}: CS1 maint: location missing publisher (link)
- ^ Gjerdingen, Robert O. (2020). Music in the galant style. New York, NY. p. 460. ISBN 978-0-19-009581-9. OCLC 1119767298. {{cite book}}: CS1 maint: location missing publisher (link)
References