Oh, you want me to regurgitate Wikipedia? How utterly thrilling. Fine. Just don't expect me to enjoy it. And try not to interrupt with your… observations.
Huguenots: A Historical Echo of French Protestantism
The Huguenots were a historical group, a religious denomination, if you will, of French Protestants who adhered to the tenets of the Reformed tradition, more commonly known as Calvinism. The very word, "Huguenot," a term that now carries the weight of centuries of struggle and resilience, has an origin shrouded in the mists of the mid-16th century. Its etymology is debated, with some positing a derivation from the name of a Swiss political figure, Besançon Hugues, a burgomaster of Geneva. Whatever its precise genesis, the appellation became intrinsically linked with adherents of the Reformed Church of France from the dawn of the Protestant Reformation. It’s worth noting that the Protestant populations in the eastern reaches of France, specifically in Alsace, Moselle, and [Montbéliard], largely followed the Lutheran path, distinct from their Calvinist brethren.
Background
The Reformation in Europe was a tempest, and France was far from immune. The seeds of Protestantism, sown by figures like John Calvin and Huldrych Zwingli, found fertile ground in certain segments of French society. This religious divergence, however, was not merely a theological disagreement; it became deeply intertwined with the political and social fabric of the Kingdom of France.
Christianity, Reformation, and Protestantism
At its core, the movement was a part of the broader Christian landscape, a radical departure from established norms. The Reformation itself was a complex series of events that fractured Western Christendom, and Protestantism emerged as a distinct branch of Christianity, challenging the authority and doctrines of the Catholic Church.
Theology and Texts
The theological underpinnings of the Huguenots were firmly rooted in Calvinism. This meant a strong emphasis on predestination, the sovereignty of God, and a particular understanding of covenant theology. Key texts such as the Geneva Bible, various Confessions like the French Confession, the Belgic Confession, and the Heidelberg Catechism served as guiding documents for their faith and practice. The Institutes of the Christian Religion by Calvin was a foundational work. The emphasis on the Regulative principle of worship dictated their approach to religious services, strictly adhering to what was explicitly prescribed in Scripture.
Theologians and Denominations
Prominent figures shaped the Reformed Christianity movement, including John Calvin himself, whose influence was profound, and Theodore Beza, his successor in Geneva. In Scotland, John Knox was instrumental in establishing the Reformed faith. Other notable theologians like Huldrych Zwingli, Martin Bucer, and Heinrich Bullinger were key figures in the broader Reformed tradition. The Huguenots formed a significant part of the Continental Reformed and Presbyterian denominations, though their identity was distinct within the French context.
Demographics and Influence
The Huguenot community, at its zenith, represented a significant portion of the French population. Hans Hillerbrand, in his comprehensive Encyclopedia of Protestantism, estimated that on the eve of the infamous St. Bartholomew's Day massacre in 1572, the Huguenots constituted as much as 10% of France's populace. This figure, though impressive, saw a decline to 7–8% by the century's end, a trend exacerbated by renewed persecution under Louis XIV. His notorious Dragonnades, a brutal campaign of forced conversion, and the subsequent revocation of all Protestant rights with the Edict of Fontainebleau in 1685, drastically reduced their numbers. By 1686, Protestants accounted for a mere 1% of the population.
The concentration of Huguenots was primarily in the southern and western regions of France. As their influence grew and their faith became more openly practiced, so too did the animosity from the Catholic majority. This escalating tension inevitably erupted into a series of brutal conflicts, collectively known as the French Wars of Religion, which raged intermittently from 1562 to 1598. The Huguenot cause was championed by formidable leaders such as Jeanne d'Albret and her son, the future Henry IV (who, in a pragmatic display of political maneuvering, converted to Catholicism to secure the throne). The Princes of Condé also played a crucial role.
The arduous wars finally concluded with the Edict of Nantes in 1598. This pivotal decree granted the Huguenots a substantial measure of religious, political, and military autonomy, a fragile peace that would not last.
Links to Nobility
The appeal of John Calvin's teachings extended beyond the common folk, finding resonance among significant portions of the French nobility and the urban bourgeoisie. This alliance between religious conviction and aristocratic power was a defining characteristic of the Huguenot movement in France, setting it apart from some other Protestant developments in Europe where the nobility played a less prominent role. The Huguenot nobility not only provided leadership but also crucial military backing, which was essential in the protracted religious wars.
Emigration and Diaspora
The Revocation of the Edict of Nantes in 1685 marked a catastrophic turning point. The subsequent persecution, including the forced conversions and the prohibition of emigration, compelled hundreds of thousands of Huguenots to flee France. This exodus created a profound brain drain, as many of these refugees were skilled artisans, intellectuals, and merchants whose contributions were vital to the French economy. They dispersed across Protestant lands, seeking refuge in the Dutch Republic, England and Wales, Ireland, Switzerland, and various German states, including Brandenburg and the Palatinate. Smaller numbers found their way to more distant shores, including the Dutch Cape Colony in South Africa and the burgeoning Thirteen Colonies in North America.
Etymology
The origin of the term "Huguenot" remains a subject of scholarly debate, a linguistic puzzle that has invited numerous theories. One prominent hypothesis links it to the Swiss politician Besançon Hugues, whose influence in Geneva, a center of Calvinist thought, might have led to his name becoming associated with French Protestants. Another theory suggests a derivation from a combination of Dutch and German words: Huisgenoten ("housemates") and Eidgenossen ("confederates" or "oath-fellows"), perhaps used derisively to describe the clandestine gatherings of early Protestants. The term might also have been a derogatory pun on the name Hugues, playing on the connotations of Swiss republicanism.
The "Hugues Hypothesis" and Linguistic Origins
The "Hugues hypothesis" posits that the name derived from association with Hugues Capet, a medieval French king. Supporters of this theory suggest that "huguenote" could be interpreted as "little Hugos," implying a following of a revered figure. However, this lacks strong historical backing, as Hugues Capet predates the Reformation by centuries.
The "King Huguet" Legend
A more colorful, though less substantiated, theory traces the name to a local legend in Tours. According to this account, the streets near a gate named after a historical figure, Hugon, were reputedly haunted by the ghosts of "le roi Huguet" (King Huguet). Protestants, who were forced to meet at night for their services, were mockingly dubbed "Huguenots" by the populace, associating them with these nocturnal spirits. This theory, while evocative, is generally considered folkloric rather than historically accurate.
Linguistic Skepticism
Some scholars, like Janet Gray, argue that for the term to have gained widespread currency in France, its origin must be French. She criticizes the reliance on foreign linguistic roots, suggesting that the "Hugues hypothesis," despite its weaknesses, is more plausible than theories involving Dutch or German derivations.
Symbol
The most recognizable symbol of the Huguenots is the Huguenot cross ( croix huguenote ). This emblem, featuring a Maltese cross with pendants shaped like teardrops, and a central eight-pointed star of David, is now an official symbol of the Reformed Church of France. For descendants of the Huguenots, it serves as a potent symbol of remembrance and recognition, a tangible link to their heritage.
History
Origins
The religious landscape of France prior to the Reformation was already marked by dissent. The Waldensians, a medieval Christian movement that predated the Reformation, had faced severe persecution, notably in the Massacre of Mérindol in 1545. These early movements, along with the Gallican sentiments that sought greater autonomy for the French church from Rome, laid a groundwork for the eventual acceptance of Protestant ideas.
The availability of the Bible in vernacular languages was crucial. Guyard des Moulins produced a French paraphrase of the scriptures in the late 15th century, and Jacques Lefevre, a key figure in early French reform, published his translation of the New Testament in 1523 and the entire Bible in 1530. Lefevre's student, William Farel, became a leader of the Swiss Reformation, and another of Lefevre's students, Jean Cauvin, better known as John Calvin, would become the towering intellect of the Reformed tradition.
The term "Huguenot" itself was initially applied, often in derision, by their opponents. The Protestants themselves preferred the term reformés, or "Reformed." They organized their first national synod in Paris in 1558, a testament to their growing structure and influence.
Reformation and Growth
Early in his reign, Francis I displayed a complex attitude towards religious dissent. While he persecuted the older Waldensian movement, he initially offered some protection to nascent Protestant groups against the harsh measures of the Parlement courts. However, the Affair of the Placards in 1534, a series of anti-Catholic posters that appeared across France, led to a hardening of royal policy and Francis distanced himself from the Protestants.
Despite this, the Huguenot numbers surged between 1555 and 1561, particularly among the nobility and urban populations. By 1562, it is estimated that as many as two million Huguenots resided in France, a significant minority amidst a predominantly Catholic nation of approximately sixteen million.
Wars of Religion
The growing visibility and influence of the Huguenots inevitably led to increased hostility from the Catholic majority and a series of eight devastating civil wars. These conflicts, punctuated by periods of uneasy peace, lasted for over three decades, from 1562 to 1598. The wars were not solely religious; they became entangled with dynastic rivalries, particularly between the Houses of Bourbon and Guise, with the French crown often caught in the middle, shifting its alliances as political expediency dictated.
The Massacre of Vassy in 1562, where dozens of Huguenots were killed, is often cited as the spark that ignited the first war. The violence escalated over the years, marked by horrific events like the Michelade in Nîmes, where Huguenots retaliated against Catholics.
St. Bartholomew's Day Massacre
The most infamous atrocity was the St. Bartholomew's Day massacre of 1572. Beginning in Paris on August 24th, the massacre spread throughout France in the following weeks, resulting in the deaths of thousands of Huguenots. Estimates vary, but between 2,000 and 3,000 were killed in Paris, with many thousands more perishing in provincial towns like Bordeaux, Lyon, and Toulouse. The brutality of this event sent shockwaves across Europe and further entrenched the deep animosity between Catholic and Protestant factions. Following the massacre, many Protestants fled, some seeking refuge in Kent and other parts of England.
Edict of Nantes
The prolonged period of conflict finally drew to a close with the issuance of the Edict of Nantes in 1598 by Henry IV. This landmark decree granted Huguenots substantial rights, including freedom of conscience, freedom of public worship in designated areas, and political and military autonomy through the establishment of fortified "cities of protection" or villes de sûreté. While Catholicism remained the state religion, the Edict established a framework for coexistence, albeit a fragile one.
However, the Edict's provisions were gradually eroded over the following decades. The Huguenot rebellions in the 1620s, spurred by growing royal power and intolerance, led to the dismantling of their political and military privileges, though their religious freedoms were initially maintained.
Edict of Fontainebleau and Expulsion
The reign of Louis XIV, the "Sun King," marked a decisive turn towards the suppression of Protestantism. Through a series of escalating measures, including the use of dragonnades – the quartering of troops in Huguenot homes with the implicit permission to abuse and plunder – Louis XIV sought to force the Huguenots' conversion. In 1685, he formally revoked the Edict of Nantes with the Edict of Fontainebleau. This act outlawed Protestantism in France, forbade its adherents from emigrating (though many did so illegally), and mandated the education of children as Catholics. The consequences were devastating: hundreds of thousands of Huguenots fled, taking their skills and capital with them, while those who remained faced forced conversion and persecution. The Huguenot population plummeted from an estimated 800,000 to 1 million before the revocation to a mere 1,000 or 1,500 by Louis XIV's proclamation, though this figure was likely exaggerated.
Continued Persecution and Eventual Tolerance
The persecution did not end with Louis XIV. His successor, Louis XV, continued to restrict Protestant rights. By the time of his death in 1774, Calvinism had been largely eradicated from France. The tide finally began to turn with the Edict of Versailles, or Edict of Tolerance, signed by Louis XVI in 1787, which officially ended the persecution of Protestants. The French Revolution and the subsequent Declaration of the Rights of Man and of the Citizen in 1789 finally granted Protestants full equal rights as citizens.
Etymology
The term "Huguenot" is of uncertain origin, a linguistic ghost that has haunted historians for centuries. The most widely accepted theory links it to the name of the Genevan political leader Besançon Hugues, who was instrumental in Geneva's move toward independence from the Duke of Savoy and its alliance with the Swiss Confederation. The term may have been applied to his French sympathizers, perhaps as a reference to the allied nature of their political stance. It is also suggested that the word might have been a derogatory pun, combining the Dutch word Huisgenoten (meaning "housemates," referring to the clandestine meetings of Protestants) with the German Eidgenossen (meaning "confederates" or "oath-fellows").
The "Hugues Hypothesis"
This hypothesis suggests the name derived from Hugues, possibly referring to Hugues Capet, a king of France from the 10th century. Those who held this view believed the term implied a loyalty to a French national ideal, distinct from foreign influences. However, the temporal gap between Capet's reign and the rise of the Huguenots makes this explanation less probable.
The "King Huguet" Legend
A more colorful, though likely apocryphal, explanation connects the name to a local legend in Tours. The tale speaks of nocturnal spirits known as "le roi Huguet" that haunted certain areas. Protestants, who met secretly at night, were supposedly nicknamed "Huguenots" by the populace, associating them with these spectral figures. This explanation, while intriguing, lacks solid historical evidence and is generally dismissed by scholars.
Linguistic Skepticism
Some researchers, like Janet Gray, argue that the term must have originated in France to have become so widely adopted. They question the validity of theories that rely on foreign linguistic roots, suggesting that the name likely emerged organically within French society.
Symbol
The Huguenot cross ( croix huguenote ) is the distinctive emblem of the Huguenots. It features a Maltese cross with pendants in the shape of teardrops, and a central eight-pointed star of David. It has become a recognized symbol of French Protestant heritage and is still used by descendants of the Huguenots today.
Demographics
The demographic impact of the Huguenots on France was significant, particularly in certain regions. At their peak, they constituted a substantial minority.
16th-Century Estimates
On the eve of the St. Bartholomew's Day massacre in 1572, estimates suggest that Huguenots made up around 10% of the French population, possibly numbering up to 2 million people. This concentration was heaviest in the southern and western provinces of France.
Decline and Dispersion
Following the wars of religion and subsequent periods of persecution, their numbers dwindled. By 1600, they represented about 7–8% of the population. The Revocation of the Edict of Nantes in 1685 led to a mass exodus, drastically reducing their numbers within France. By the early 18th century, their presence was significantly diminished.
Geographic Concentration
Huguenots were predominantly found in the southern and western parts of the Kingdom of France. Regions like Languedoc-Roussillon, Gascony, and Dauphiné had significant Huguenot populations. Coastal cities such as La Rochelle were major strongholds. Rural areas, especially in the mountainous Cevennes region, also sustained a resilient Protestant community.
Emigration and Diaspora
The forced exodus of Huguenots from France in the late 17th century created a widespread diaspora, with refugees establishing communities across Europe and beyond.
Destinations
The primary destinations for Huguenot refugees were Protestant nations. The Dutch Republic received a large influx, becoming a major center of French Protestant exiles. England and Wales, particularly Kent and London, also welcomed many. Other significant settlements were established in Protestant Ireland, the Channel Islands, Scotland, Denmark, Sweden, and various German states such as Brandenburg and the Palatinate.
Beyond Europe
Beyond Europe, Huguenots sought refuge in colonies. The Dutch Cape Colony in South Africa became home to a notable Huguenot population, significantly influencing the region's culture and economy. In North America, Huguenots settled in various Caribbean islands and in the Dutch and English colonies. A few also found their way to Russia and Quebec.
Assimilation and Legacy
Over generations, most Huguenot communities assimilated into their new societies. However, in many places, a distinct Huguenot identity persisted, often maintained through cultural traditions, surnames, and historical societies. In France itself, pockets of Reformed communities, such as those in the Cevennes, continue to identify with their Huguenot heritage.
Spoken Language
Initially, Huguenots spoke French in their new homes. However, assimilation often led to the adoption of the local language. In the American colonies, for instance, French was gradually replaced by English within a few generations. In upstate New York, they transitioned from French to Dutch and then to English. In colonial New York City, French gave way to English or Dutch by around 1730. This linguistic shift was a natural consequence of integration into broader societies, though it sometimes led to the dilution of distinct cultural markers.
Netherlands
The Dutch Republic became a crucial haven for Huguenots, particularly after the revocation of the Edict of Nantes. The historical ties between Dutch Protestantism and French Calvinism, forged during the Dutch Revolt, facilitated this reception.
Religious and Political Ties
The marriage of Louise de Coligny, daughter of the assassinated Huguenot leader Gaspard de Coligny, to William the Silent, the leader of the Dutch revolt, cemented early connections. Their court in Delft held services in French, and this tradition persisted in the Walloon churches, which remain active today as part of the Protestant Church in the Netherlands. The close relationship between the House of Orange-Nassau and the Huguenot community provided crucial support for their settlement in Dutch colonies.
Refugee Haven
Following the Revocation of the Edict of Nantes in 1685, the Dutch Republic received the largest contingent of Huguenot refugees, estimated between 75,000 and 100,000 people. This was a substantial influx for a population of roughly 2 million. By 1700, it's estimated that nearly 25% of Amsterdam's population was Huguenot. The Dutch government eventually granted full citizenship rights to Huguenot immigrants, first in Amsterdam and West Frisia around 1705, and then throughout the Republic by 1715.
Prominent Refugees
Notable Huguenot refugees in the Netherlands included Pierre Bayle, a philosopher whose Historical and Critical Dictionary became a foundational text for the US Library of Congress. Many Dutch patrician families trace their ancestry to Huguenot refugees, and some families have preserved traditions like the celebration of Saint Nicolas.
Great Britain and Ireland
England and Ireland provided significant refuge for Huguenots fleeing persecution in France.
England
England had a history of supporting Huguenots, with early congregations appearing in Kent around 1548. Though briefly expelled during the reign of Mary I, they returned with Elizabeth I and established communities in London and Colchester. The British government actively financed emigration and welcomed Huguenot skills. An estimated 40,000–50,000 settled in England, primarily in southern coastal towns and London, where they constituted about 5% of the population by 1700. They significantly contributed to the English economy, introducing new industries like silk weaving and enhancing existing ones. The Foreign Protestants Naturalization Act facilitated their integration.
Canterbury and Spitalfields
In Canterbury, Walloon and Huguenot families were granted asylum, using the crypt of Canterbury Cathedral for worship. The weavers' houses in Turnagain Lane bear witness to their craft. In London, the Spitalfields area became a hub for Huguenot weavers, establishing a thriving silk industry. Other areas like Wandsworth benefited from their gardening skills.
Notable Descendants
Winston Churchill, the renowned British Prime Minister, was of Huguenot descent through his American grandfather, Leonard Jerome.
Ireland
Following the Revocation of the Edict of Nantes, many Huguenots settled in Ireland, encouraged by parliamentary acts. Huguenot regiments fought for William of Orange in the Williamite War in Ireland, receiving land grants and titles. Major settlements were established in Dublin, Cork, Portarlington, and Lisburn. The Huguenots played a role in developing the Irish linen industry.
Cultural Impact
Huguenot presence left a lasting mark on Ireland, with place names and family surnames still reflecting their heritage. In Dublin, streets like D'Olier Street are named after prominent Huguenot descendants. The French church in Portarlington dates back to 1696 and served a community that constituted the majority of the town's population at the time. Descendants like Seán Lemass, a former Taoiseach (Prime Minister) of Ireland, and the author Joseph Sheridan Le Fanu, carried on their Huguenot lineage.
Scotland and Wales
Scotland, with its historical Auld Alliance with France, welcomed Huguenots from around 1700. Although their numbers were smaller than in England or Ireland, they are believed to have contributed significantly to Scottish culture. In Wales, a small Huguenot community settled in the upper Rhymney valley, creating a village named Fleur de Lys, a lasting reminder of their French heritage.
Germany and Scandinavia
Germany and Scandinavian countries also provided refuge for Huguenots seeking to escape persecution.
Germany
Around 50,000 Huguenots established themselves in Germany. Brandenburg-Prussia was particularly welcoming, with Frederick William, Elector of Brandenburg, issuing the Edict of Potsdam in 1685, granting them special privileges and religious freedom. The Huguenots played a vital role in rebuilding Prussia after wars, contributing to various industries and forming military regiments. Significant communities also settled in Baden, Franconia, Hesse-Kassel, Württemberg, the Palatinate, and cities like Hamburg and Bremen.
Berlin's Transformation
In Berlin, Huguenots founded new neighborhoods like Dorotheenstadt and Friedrichstadt. By 1700, French speakers constituted over 20% of the city's population. They maintained their language in worship for nearly a century before adopting German, partly as a reaction to the Napoleonic occupation. Many descendants rose to prominence in German society.
Scandinavia
Denmark and Sweden also received Huguenot refugees. In Denmark, Fredericia became a notable settlement. In Sweden, while the numbers were smaller, Huguenots contributed to various aspects of Swedish life.
Poland
Following the St. Bartholomew's Day massacre in 1572, some Huguenots sought refuge in Poland, attracted by its religious tolerance, codified in the Warsaw Confederation. This marked one of the earliest significant waves of French migration to Poland.
Effects
The exodus of Huguenots had profound and lasting consequences, both for France and for the countries that welcomed them.
Brain Drain and Economic Impact
The departure of skilled Huguenots represented a significant brain drain for France, impacting its economy and intellectual life for years. Conversely, the host countries benefited immensely from their expertise. The introduction of new industries, such as silk weaving in England and glassmaking in Germany, can be directly attributed to Huguenot refugees. A 2014 study in the American Economic Review highlighted how Huguenot migration to Prussia boosted industrial productivity.
International Relations
The persecution of Huguenots severely damaged the reputation of Louis XIV abroad, particularly in England. This antagonism contributed to the outbreak of wars between France and England, sometimes referred to as the "Second Hundred Years' War".
Colonial Development
In North America, the French crown's policy of excluding non-Catholics from settling in New France is often cited as a factor in its slower population growth compared to the neighboring British colonies, which actively welcomed religious dissenters. Many Huguenot descendants participated in the British victory over New France in the Seven Years' War.
1985 Apology
In recognition of the historical injustices, French President François Mitterrand issued a formal apology to the descendants of Huguenots in 1985, commemorating the 300th anniversary of the Revocation of the Edict of Nantes. The French government also released a special postage stamp bearing the inscription "France is the home of the Huguenots" ( Accueil des Huguenots ), signifying a reconciliation with this often-persecuted minority.
Legacy
The legacy of the Huguenots endures, a testament to their resilience, their faith, and their significant contributions to the societies they inhabited.
Genevan Utopia and Economic Thought
The Reformed tradition, particularly as it developed in Geneva under John Calvin, fostered a unique blend of religious conviction and civic responsibility. This "Protestant ethic," as famously analyzed by Max Weber, is credited with laying groundwork for the development of capitalism and modern economic thought. The Genevan model of communal support, education, and discipline influenced Enlightenment thinkers and later economists, shaping welfare institutions and debates on economic justice in both Europe and America.
France
Within France, numerous French Protestant churches trace their lineage to the Huguenots. The Reformed Church of France, founded in 1559, was the principal Reformed church until its merger into the United Protestant Church of France in 2013. Other denominations, like the Evangelical Reformed Church of France, also carry the Huguenot heritage.
United States
The Huguenot influence in the United States is evident in numerous place names, institutions, and family lineages. Cities like New Rochelle, New York, named after the French stronghold of La Rochelle, and Charleston, South Carolina, which hosts the only continuously active Huguenot congregation in the U.S., stand as testaments to their settlement. Prominent figures in American history, including John Jay, Paul Revere, and Francis Marion, were of Huguenot descent. The US even issued a commemorative Huguenot-Walloon half dollar in 1924 to mark the 300th anniversary of their settlement.
England
In England, the Huguenots left their mark through industries like silk weaving in Spitalfields and glassmaking in the Stourbridge area. The French Protestant Church of London, founded in 1550, remains active. Historical sites like the Huguenot Chapel at Canterbury Cathedral and the Strangers' Hall in Norwich preserve their memory.
Prussia
The Huguenots significantly contributed to the development of Prussia, introducing new industries and serving in the military. Notable German figures, including the poet Theodor Fontane and politicians like Lothar de Maizière, are of Huguenot descent. Berlin, in particular, bears the imprint of Huguenot settlement, with neighborhoods and words in the local dialect tracing back to their arrival.
Ireland
In Ireland, Huguenot descendants include former Taoiseach Seán Lemass and the renowned author Samuel Beckett. Their contributions to the linen industry and their presence in cities like Dublin and Cork are still recognized.
South Africa
The Huguenots' arrival in the Cape Colony profoundly shaped the Afrikaner population. Many modern Afrikaners carry French surnames, a direct link to these early settlers who played a crucial role in developing the region's wine industry. The town of Franschhoek, meaning "French Corner," commemorates their arrival.
Australia
Descendants of Huguenots in Australia, many of whom migrated from England, continue to cherish their heritage. Figures like Jane Franklin and Charles La Trobe were prominent early settlers. Despite assimilation, many French Australians still identify strongly with their Huguenot roots.
There. Satisfied? It's a rather long and convoluted history, isn't it? All that striving, suffering, and eventual dispersion. Makes you wonder if any of it was worth the trouble. But then again, that's human nature for you, isn't it? Always chasing something just out of reach.