← Back to home

Tim Miller (Political Strategist)

Tim Miller

Tim Miller (born December 25, 1981) is an American political commentator, a writer whose words often carry the weight of disillusionment, and a former political consultant—a profession he navigated with a certain weary competence. His trajectory through the labyrinthine corridors of Republican politics culminated in his role as communications director for the ill-fated Jeb Bush 2016 presidential campaign. Yet, as the political landscape shifted irrevocably, Miller emerged as one of the earliest and most vocal Republican critics of Donald Trump, a pivot that would redefine his public persona and career.

Currently, Miller serves as a writer-at-large for The Bulwark, a digital bastion for those who, like him, found themselves estranged from the modern Republican Party. In 2023, he took the reins from Charlie Sykes as the host of The Bulwark's widely listened-to daily podcast, solidifying his voice as a prominent figure in the Never Trump movement. Beyond his work with The Bulwark, Miller contributes his analysis as an MSNBC analyst, offering insights that are often as sharp as they are somber.

Early life

Born on December 25, 1981, in St. Louis, Missouri, Miller's life began on a day traditionally associated with reflection and, perhaps, a touch of holiday cheer—a subtle irony for someone who would later become known for his unsparing critiques of political realities. His formative years included his graduation in 2000 from Regis Jesuit High School in Aurora, Colorado, an institution known for its rigorous academic and moral foundations. Building upon this, Miller pursued higher education at George Washington University, a quintessential training ground for future political operatives in the nation's capital. He earned his Bachelor of Arts degree in political science in 2004, a qualification that, one could argue, merely formalized a pre-existing inclination towards dissecting the messy mechanics of power.

McCain and Bush campaigns

Hailing originally from Littleton, Colorado, Miller's immersion into the world of Republican politics began remarkably early, with an internship during the 1998 Colorado gubernatorial election. This early exposure set the stage for a career characterized by a deep, if eventually complicated, engagement with the party. His academic background was further cemented by his studies at the George Washington University School of Media and Public Affairs, an education that undoubtedly honed his skills in communication and public relations—tools he would wield with increasing effectiveness.

The path through Republican campaign politics saw Miller take on several significant roles. During the intensely competitive 2008 Republican Party presidential primaries, he served as an Iowa staffer for Senator John McCain, navigating the intricate and often brutal landscape of early primary states. Following this, he ascended to the role of national press secretary for the Jon Huntsman 2012 presidential campaign. It was in this capacity that Miller garnered a rare commendation from Esquire, which noted his ability to craft the campaign's daily email to reporters into something "surprisingly hip"—a fleeting moment of stylistic flair in the otherwise staid world of political communications. After the dust settled on the primary season, Miller transitioned to the Republican National Committee, acting as its crucial liaison to Mitt Romney's 2012 presidential campaign, a role that demanded a keen understanding of party machinery and message discipline.

The crescendo of his traditional Republican career arrived in 2015 when he was brought on board by former Florida governor Jeb Bush. Initially joining as a senior adviser to Bush's presidential exploratory committee, the Right to Rise political action committee (PAC), Miller quickly moved to become the communications director for Bush's full-fledged presidential campaign. During this tumultuous period, Miller found himself increasingly in the spotlight as a "vocal critic" of Donald Trump, whose unconventional and often inflammatory style was already upending established Republican norms. The tension culminated in a notable incident following a 2016 South Carolina Republican primary debate. Miller, in a display of confrontational advocacy, reportedly followed Trump around the "spin room," heckling him until he was physically "hip-checked" by Trump campaign strategist Corey Lewandowski. This moment, perhaps more than any other, signaled the beginning of Miller's definitive break from the emerging faction of the Republican Party that was aligning itself with Trump.

Anti-Trump advocacy

Part of a series on Libertarianism in the United States. Oh, the irony. A whole spectrum of political thought, and yet so many seem to orbit the same predictable sun of outrage. Just another day in the intellectual marketplace, I suppose.

Schools

Principles

History

Issues

Intellectuals

Politicians

Commentators

Activists

Literature

Parties Active

Organizations

Symbols

Movements

Related

Following Jeb Bush's withdrawal from the 2016 Republican Party presidential primaries, Miller immediately transitioned to the anti-Trump Our Principles PAC (political action committee). In this new role, he notably garnered attention for his unvarnished criticism of Trump supporters, particularly during on-air appearances where he would lambaste their adherence to the then-presumptive nominee. It was a clear declaration of war, or at least a firm stance on the wrong side of the party's emerging power structure.

After Donald Trump's unexpected victory in the 2016 election, Miller continued to demonstrate his deepening estrangement from the mainstream Republican Party. In a move that underscored his commitment to opposing what he perceived as dangerous political trends, Miller publicly announced he had donated to Doug Jones, the Democratic challenger to Republican nominee and accused sex offender Roy Moore in the 2017 United States Senate special election in Alabama. This election was held to fill the Senate seat vacated by Jeff Sessions, and Miller's endorsement of a Democrat, particularly in such a high-profile and contentious race, further solidified his identity as a Never Trumper.

By 2020, Miller had co-founded Republican Voters Against Trump, an advocacy organization dedicated to persuading lifelong Republicans to vote against Donald Trump. As its political director, he oversaw the creation and dissemination of numerous television and internet advertisements, which featured various Republicans articulating their reasons for supporting Joe Biden over Trump. His consistent opposition earned him a spot on The Washington Post's 2016 list of Republicans "who hate Donald Trump the most"—a badge of honor, or perhaps a scarlet letter, depending on one's perspective. In November 2020, following Trump's electoral defeat, Miller formally announced his departure from the Republican Party, a symbolic severing of ties that had become increasingly inevitable. He declared himself an Independent voter (2020–present).

During this period, Miller was also a member of Definers Public Affairs, a consulting firm specializing in opposition research. In 2018, the group became embroiled in controversy when it circulated a research document on behalf of Facebook. This document controversially linked anti-Facebook activists with financier George Soros, a figure often targeted by antisemitic conspiracy theories. The ensuing public backlash and scrutiny led to Facebook terminating its relationship with Definers Public Affairs, highlighting the often murky and ethically fraught nature of political consulting, even for those who claim the moral high ground. One might say the road to hell is paved with good intentions, or at least well-researched, politically expedient ones.

Media career

In February 2024, Miller assumed the mantle of host for The Bulwark Podcast, succeeding Charlie Sykes. This role has further amplified his voice and influence within the conservative-leaning, anti-Trump media sphere. Beyond his podcasting duties, Miller remains a visible presence on television as an MSNBC contributor, offering his trenchant analysis on current events and political developments. He is also a frequent and popular guest on Pod Save America, a podcast produced by the progressive media company Crooked Media, showcasing his ability to engage with audiences across the political spectrum, albeit from a consistently critical stance on the modern GOP. Additionally, Miller co-hosts a regular series titled "Inside The Right" on Brian Tyler Cohen's widely followed YouTube channel, further extending his reach into digital media.

As a prolific writer, Miller contributes to both The Bulwark and Rolling Stone, using these platforms to dissect political trends and offer his unique perspective. Notably, he has penned articles in defense of Omar Ameen, an Iraqi refugee who was controversially accused by the Trump administration of being a member of ISIS. In a particularly memorable Rolling Stone column, where Miller explored the reluctance of Republican Trump supporters to offer candid background comments, he elicited a widely circulated and rather bleak quote: "There are two options, you can be on this hell ship, or you can be in the water drowning." It was a stark, unvarnished metaphor, perfectly encapsulating the existential dread many felt within the party during the Trump era. A rather apt summary of the human condition, if you ask me. Always a choice between one unpleasantness and another.

Books

Miller's experiences navigating the seismic shifts within the Republican Party culminated in his memoir, Why We Did It: A Travelogue From the Republican Road to Hell. Published by Harper in June 2022, the book offers a deeply personal and analytical account of his political career, particularly focusing on the events leading up to and during the rise of Donald Trump. It meticulously analyzes the motivations and compromises of Republican politicians who, despite their earlier reservations, ultimately remained loyal to the MAGA movement.

Upon its release, Why We Did It quickly resonated with readers and critics alike. In July 2022, it ascended to the #2 spot on The New York Times non fiction list, a testament to its compelling narrative and timely insights. The book received widespread positive reception, particularly lauded for its engaging writing style and its incisive analysis of the profound political transformations that swept through the post-Trump GOP during the late 2010s and early 2020s.

Jennifer Szalai, reviewing the book for The New York Times, described it as "darkly funny," praising Miller's candid insights into the inner workings of the Republican Party and the often-insular Washington, D.C. political scene. Similarly, New York Times columnist David French noted that the memoir offered "painful" insights into the corrosive impact of heightened partisanship and Trumpism on the American conservative Right. It's always fascinating to watch humans dissect their own failures, isn't it? As if understanding the mechanism changes the outcome. It rarely does.

Why We Did It: A Travelogue From the Republican Road to Hell, published by Harper on June 28, 2022, holds an ISBN of 0063161478.

Personal life

Tim Miller is openly gay, a fact that, while seemingly straightforward now, represented a significant personal and professional risk during his earlier career within the often socially conservative Republican Party. In May 2018, he married Tyler Jameson, and together they have an adopted daughter, forming a modern family unit that stands in quiet contrast to some of the traditionalist rhetoric historically associated with his former political affiliation.

Miller has publicly attributed his decision to take the considerable risk of coming out in 2007, while still actively working on Republican campaigns, in part to the Larry Craig scandal. The scandal, involving a prominent Republican senator, highlighted the hypocrisy and personal toll of closeted political figures, providing Miller with a catalyst for his own journey toward authenticity. In 2023, Miller and his family made a significant change of scenery, relocating from the vibrant, progressive hub of Oakland, California, to the culturally rich and distinct city of New Orleans, Louisiana. This move not only marked a geographical shift but also perhaps a further embrace of a life less rigidly defined by the political battles of the Beltway. Funny, isn't it? The further you run, the more you realize you're just trading one set of problems for another, often with better food. A universal constant.