← Back to home

South China Sea

Right. Let's not waste time with pleasantries. You want to know about the South China Sea. Fine. It's a massive, rather contentious body of water, nestled in the embrace of the Western Pacific Ocean. Picture this: a vast expanse, roughly 3.5 million square kilometers – that’s about 1.4 million square miles, if you need it spelled out. It’s bordered to the north by South China, to the west by the Indochinese Peninsula, and to the east by the Taiwan island and the northwestern Philippines, specifically Luzon, Mindoro, and Palawan. Down south, it kisses Borneo, eastern Sumatra, and the Bangka Belitung Islands. It’s not exactly a solitary entity; it bleeds into other seas – the East China Sea through the Taiwan Strait, the Philippine Sea via the Luzon Strait, the Sulu Sea through the straits around Palawan, the Java Sea via the Karimata and Bangka Straits, and even directly with the Gulf of Thailand. Oh, and the Gulf of Tonkin? Yeah, that’s part of it too.

Geography

The sheer scale of this sea is almost… vulgar. Imagine 3.4trillionoftheworld′s3.4 trillion of the world's 16 trillion in maritime shipping – that’s a lot of metal and ambition – slithering through its waters in 2016 alone. And it’s not just a highway; it’s a treasure chest, supposedly brimming with oil and natural gas. In 2010, this part of the Western Pacific, excluding the bits closest to the Chinese coast, was responsible for 14% of the world's commercial fishing. Up from less than 4 million tonnes in 1970. So, you have trade, resources, and a whole lot of water.

And then there are the islands. Hundreds of them. Mostly small, mostly uninhabited, a collection of archipelago clusters, cays, shoals, reefs/atolls, and seamounts. These aren't just pretty rocks; they’re the focal point of a rather nasty territorial dispute, with several countries squabbling over who gets to plant their flag. This is reflected in the dizzying array of names thrown around for both the islands and the sea itself. It’s a geopolitical mess, frankly.

Etymology

The name "South China Sea" itself is, predictably, a European import. It arose from early European interest in the sea as a route to China's lucrative trading ports. Portuguese sailors in the 16th century called it Mare da China. Later, to distinguish it from other nearby bodies of water, it became the "South China Sea." The International Hydrographic Organization officially recognizes it as such, though they tack on the Chinese name, Nan Hai, for good measure.

The Chinese themselves have a longer history with this water. The Yizhoushu, a chronicle from the Western Zhou dynasty, refers to it as Nanfang Hai, the "Southern Sea." Later classics, like the Classic of Poetry and Zuo Zhuan, mention Nan Hai, the "South Sea," in relation to the State of Chu's maritime endeavors. Nan Hai was one of the Four Seas in Chinese literature, each representing a cardinal direction. During the Eastern Han dynasty, it was known as Zhang Hai, the "distended sea." The Southern and Northern dynasties saw it called Fei Hai, the "boiling sea." The current name, Nan Hai, became more prevalent during the Qing dynasty.

In Southeast Asia, it was once known as the Champa Sea, or Sea of Cham, after the ancient kingdom of Champa. During World War II, the Japanese occupied much of the region and referred to it as Minami Shina Kai, or "South China Sea." The spelling has shifted over time, but the sentiment remains.

In Vietnam, it’s called Biển Đông, the "East Sea." In Malaysia, Indonesia, and the Philippines, "South China Sea" is the common term, though the Philippines sometimes refers to the waters within its territorial reach as the "Luzon Sea," or Dagat Luzon.

More recently, in response to escalating disputes, the Philippines officially designated parts of the sea within its exclusive economic zone as the West Philippine Sea. Indonesia, too, has asserted its claims by renaming its portion north of the Natuna Islands the "North Natuna Sea." This renaming, while official government policy, hasn't necessarily settled anything with China, who remains rather ambiguous about its own territorial limits.

Hydrography

The sea is fed by a number of significant rivers, including the Pearl, Min, Jiulong, Red, Mekong, Menam, Rajang, Baram, Kapuas, Batang Hari, Musi, Kampar, Indragiri, Pahang, Agno, Pampanga, and Pasig Rivers.

The International Hydrographic Organization, in its 1953 edition of Limits of Oceans and Seas, defined the boundaries of the South China Sea with a level of detail that suggests a certain meticulousness, if not outright obsession. These boundaries delineate the sea from its neighbors, tracing lines through straits and along coastlines, from the southern tip of Johore to the northernmost point of Taiwan. It’s a complex web of geographical definitions, which, of course, are now subject to revision and debate. A 1986 draft edition already proposed altering the southern limit to include the Natuna Islands, a subtle but significant shift.

The sea itself boasts an average depth of 1,212 meters (3,976 feet), with its deepest point plunging to around 5,560 meters (18,240 feet).

Geology

This entire submerged landscape was once a dry continental shelf. During the recent ice ages, when sea levels were considerably lower, Borneo was a mere peninsula attached to the Asian mainland. The South China Sea basin itself began to form around 45 million years ago, during the Eocene, when the area now known as the "Dangerous Ground" rifted away from southern China. This process of extension and seafloor spreading continued, shaping the basin into its current V-shape. The active tectonics, possibly driven by the collision of India with Asia, pushed Indochina southeastward, a theory proposed by Paul Tapponnier and his colleagues, though not universally accepted. Evidence from the Red River Fault suggests basin formation was underway by 37 million years ago. Over eons, rivers like the Mekong, Red, and Pearl have deposited vast amounts of sediment, creating deltas that are now rich in valuable oil and gas deposits.

Islands and Seamounts

The sea is littered with over 250 islands, atolls, cays, shoals, reefs, and sandbars. Most are uninhabited, many are submerged at high tide, and some are perpetually underwater. The most prominent of these are the Spratly Islands, the Paracel Islands, Pratas Island with its Vereker Banks, the Macclesfield Bank, and the Scarborough Shoal.

The Spratlys, spread across a vast area, comprise some 175 features. The largest, Taiping Island (also known as Itu Aba), is a meager 1.3 kilometers long and reaches a maximum elevation of a mere 3.8 meters. A truly colossal feature in the Spratly group is the Reed Tablemount, or Reed Bank, a submerged seamount spanning 100 kilometers. It was once an island, drowned by rising sea levels after the last ice age, and is now one of the world's largest submerged atoll structures.

Trade Route

This sea has been a crucial artery for trade for centuries, connecting northeast Asia, China, Southeast Asia, and onward to India and the West. The numerous shipwrecks scattered across its floor are silent testaments to this vibrant history. Nine ancient trading vessels, dating from the 10th to the 19th centuries, have been recovered, laden with ceramics.

Even today, its importance is undeniable. In 2016, $3.4 trillion of global maritime trade passed through its waters. By 2019, that figure represented about 5% of global GDP. And let's not forget the millions of barrels of crude oil that traverse these waters daily.

Natural Resources

Despite the strategic importance and the claims, estimates from the United States Energy Information Administration in 2012-2013 suggested that the contested areas, like the Paracels and Spratlys, hold relatively little conventional oil and natural gas. The bulk of the estimated 11 billion barrels of oil and 190 trillion cubic feet of natural gas are found closer to undisputed coastlines.

As for fish, the Western Central Pacific, which includes significant portions of the South China Sea, accounted for 14% of the global commercial catch in 2010. China announced a supposed breakthrough in 2017 for mining methane clathrates, though commercial viability is still a decade or more away.

Territorial Claims

Now, this is where things get truly tiresome. Multiple countries have staked claims to this sea and its islands, turning it into one of Asia’s most volatile flashpoints. The People's Republic of China and the Republic of China (Taiwan) both claim almost the entire sea, demarcated by the notorious "nine-dash line". These claims inevitably overlap with those of other nations:

China and Vietnam have been particularly aggressive in asserting their claims. Before 1974, both China and South Vietnam controlled parts of the Paracel Islands. A brief, bloody conflict in 1974 resulted in significant casualties, and China has held the islands since. The Spratlys have also seen naval clashes, most notably a 1988 confrontation where over 70 Vietnamese sailors perished. These incidents are not isolated; naval vessels from various nations regularly report confrontations.

ASEAN, particularly Malaysia, has pushed for de-escalation and cooperative development in disputed areas, especially in the Gulf of Thailand, to avoid armed conflict. China, however, prefers bilateral negotiations, while some ASEAN members advocate for multilateral talks, feeling outmatched in one-on-one discussions.

The dispute over Pedra Branca (or Pulau Batu Putih) and the adjacent Middle Rocks between Singapore and Malaysia was finally settled by the International Court of Justice in 2008.

In 2010, US Secretary of State Hillary Clinton called for China to resolve the disputes, a move China met with a demand for the US to stay out. This occurred during a period of heightened tensions, marked by naval exercises from both sides. The US Department of Defense subsequently voiced opposition to the use of force.

An incident in 2011 saw an Indian naval vessel, the INS Airavat, contacted by a vessel identifying as Chinese Navy and claiming the area was Chinese territory. India, however, maintained its right to freedom of navigation. Later that year, India's Oil and Natural Gas Corporation (ONGC) signed a deal with Vietnam for oil exploration in the South China Sea, drawing a protest from China. India's response was to adhere to the agreements made with Vietnamese authorities.

Taiwan's claim in 1999, under the Lee Teng-hui administration, asserted sovereignty over the entirety of the South China Sea islands, including their subsoil, seabed, and waters. In 2012 and 2013, tensions flared between Taiwan and Vietnam over Taiwanese military exercises near the Spratly Islands.

China's deployment of an oil rig near the Paracel Islands in May 2014 led to direct confrontations between Vietnamese and Chinese ships, a strategic shift observed since 2012.

More recently, retired Chinese admiral Luo Yuan controversially suggested sinking US aircraft carriers as a means to deter American presence. Similarly, Chinese commentator Colonel Dai Xu proposed ramming US Navy ships.

Despite not being a signatory to UNCLOS, the US maintains its right to sail unhindered through the South China Sea, occasionally sailing within the 12-nautical-mile limit of Chinese-controlled islands, which has drawn strong reactions from China. Rules of engagement were reportedly established between US and Chinese naval counterparts in early 2019.

In June 2020, the 36th ASEAN Summit, chaired by Vietnam, emphasized the importance of UNCLOS as the legal framework for maritime activities. In November 2025, Australia voiced concerns over China's military expansion, citing risks to trade routes and referencing an incident where a Chinese jet dropped flares near an Australian patrol plane.

2016 Arbitration

In 2013, the Philippines initiated arbitration proceedings against China concerning the nine-dash line, the classification of maritime features, and exclusive economic zones. China, predictably, refused to participate.

On July 12, 2016, an arbitral tribunal largely ruled in favor of the Philippines. It stated that China had no legal basis for its "historic rights" claims within the nine-dash line, as it had not exercised exclusive control. The ruling also found that China's claims had no lawful effect outside the entitlements granted by UNCLOS. The tribunal criticized China's land reclamation and artificial island construction for causing "severe harm to the coral reef environment." Furthermore, it classified Taiping Island and other Spratly features as "rocks," not entitled to an exclusive economic zone. This decision was declared final and non-appealable.

China rejected the ruling outright, deeming it "ill-founded" and continuing to push for bilateral discussions. Taiwan also rejected the ruling. As of November 2023, a significant number of governments supported the ruling, while a smaller group opposed it. The United Nations itself maintains a neutral stance on the legal merits but expressed hope for continued dialogue.

Honestly, it's a mess. A vast, resource-rich, strategically vital mess. And everyone wants a piece.